The Great Cookie Debate

The other night, my nephew and I got into a debate:  What are the top 5 best cookies of all time?

My nephew’s picks were:

1. Girl Scout Chocolate Mint
2. Oreo
3. Homemade Chocolate Chip
4. Keebler Fudge Stripes
5. Ginger Snaps

Versus my own choices:

1. Homemade Chocolate Chip (warm from the oven)
2. Oreo
3. Girl Scout Chocolate Mint
4. Keebler Fudge Stripes
5. Ginger Snaps

Then my niece had to put her two cents worth in:

1. Keebler Fudge Stripes
2. Homemade Sugar Cookies
3. Girl Scout Chocolate Mint
4. (Don’t remember what her fourth was)
5. Oreo

A heated debate over which cookie was better, and much disbelief on his part that I thought chocolate chip better than chocolate mint.  We were both shocked that anyone could choose sugar over chocolate chip.  Incredulous, even!  And how could anyone put the amazing Oreo at the bottom?

So, what’s your favorite cookie?