Clash of the Gods

Have any of you been watching this show?  It’s about finding truth in the various mythical stories and legends of the world.   For the most part, I find the various commentaries to be interesting and insightful, except for the last couple of subjects:  The Odyssey and Beowulf.

The Odyssey

Not once, in the two episodes it took to discuss this story, did they mention the involvement of Athena.  They went on and on about the wrath of Poseidon, but not one single word about Athena.  Poseidon, the god of the sea, horses, and earthquakes versus Athena, goddess of wisdom, crafts, and war.  The power of natural chaos versus the order of the human mind.  This is one of the predominant themes of Greek mythology.

Beowulf.

First, the sword and scabbard.  I did not notice this, my nephew pointed it out to me.  The man who plays Beowulf wears his scabbard on his right side as if he fights left-handed, but, most of the time, he holds the sword in his right hand.

Second, the scholars talk about how, in this story, we see the Christianization of the old oral tales, but they neglect to mention one of the most obviously Christian allusions in the entire poem:  Hrothgar’s queen.

Third, the fact that they referenced the Icelandic sagas for the Battle on the Ice, but did not mention Bjorn Bjarki, the hero of that battle in the sagas.  Bjarki was, supposedly, part bear.  Beowulf translates into modern English as “bee wolf.”  A clear reference to a bear. 

And, fourth, in looking for historical evidence for people mentioned in the poem, they neglected to mention that there is a possible reference to the death of Beowulf’s overlord, King Hygelac of the Geats, in a Frankish chronicle:  The History of the Franks by Geoffrey of Tours.

Advertisements

One thought on “Clash of the Gods

  1. I was googling “Clash of the Gods Athena” and stumbled across your blog, lol. Athena is my favorite character from Greek mythology and I’ve been hoping for episodes that revolve around her and Artemis.

    The greatest thing about Greek mythology is not the “truth” in the religions, but the greatest thing about Greek mythology is the fact that women commonly exist as equals to the male Gods. I hope they do a series on Tyche and Venus too. It doesn’t look like they’re going too, though, it appears the History channel has become sexist. (Kidding.)

    It’d also be nice to see an episode for Pandora, afterall Eve is based on her. It’s fair to say that Mary is at least loosely based on Athena/Artemis/Hera, since all three of them were rumored to of been virgin mothers.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s